Position Information

The position information for this posting is listed below.
Click on the "Apply for this Position" link below to apply for this posting.
Mutual Insurance Company Manager
Property Underwriting Experience Preferred
 
An established, well-capitalized Illinois farm mutual insurance company is seeking an experienced manager with a strong background in property underwriting.
Serving more than 5,000 policyholders across 46 Illinois counties, our company works through an extensive network of independent insurance agencies to provide dependable, personalized insurance solutions.
The ideal candidate will bring insurance company management experience, strong leadership abilities, excellent interpersonal skills, and a solid understanding of property underwriting and the property/casualty insurance industry.
 
Desirable Qualifications for a Mutual Manager
  • Education: Bachelor’s degree or equivalent work experience required.
  • Industry Experience: Minimum of five to seven years of property/casualty insurance industry experience in major functional areas such as underwriting, claims, marketing, education, or reinsurance.
  • Farm Mutual Experience: Previous experience in the farm mutual insurance industry is highly desirable.
  • Management Experience: Prior management experience is strongly preferred.
  • Communication Skills: Effective oral and written communication and interpersonal skills are required.
  • Leadership and Decision-Making: Strong analytical, strategic, decision-making, and problem-solving skills are essential.
  • Computer Skills: Proficiency with computers and relevant software is required, including Microsoft Outlook, Word, and Excel. Experience with Microsoft PowerPoint and Publisher is a plus. Experience or expertise with comparable software will also be considered.
  • Professional Development: Continuing education in the insurance industry is preferred, including designations such as Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU), Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC), or Professional Farm Mutual Manager (PFMM).
The Opportunity
 
This is an excellent opportunity, with competitive salary and benefits package, for an experienced insurance professional to lead and contribute to the continued success of a financially sound mutual insurance company. The successful candidate will have the opportunity to apply their underwriting knowledge, management experience, and relationship-building skills while serving policyholders and independent insurance agencies throughout the company's territory.
 
Interested candidates are encouraged to submit a résumé and cover letter outlining their relevant insurance industry experience, management background, and qualifications to susan@bradfordmutual.com.
Position: Mutual Insurance Company Manager
Organization: Bradford Mutual Insurance Company
Location: Franklin Grove,  IL 
United States
Salary:
Posting Start Date: 10/26/2026
Date Posted: 10/26/2026
Requirements
Status: This listing expires on: 1/24/2027
Apply Apply for this Position
Send to a Friend  Send to Friend
   Print Job
Return to Job Search  Return to Job Search
Post a Position  Post a Position
Organization Information
Name:
Bradford Mutual Insurance Company
Address:
120 W South St

Franklin Grove,  IL 61031
United States
Email:
susan@bradfordmutual.com
Phone:
(815) 456-2334
Fax:
Contact:

Upcoming Events

2026 WAMIC Convention
View All Events